Does David de Gea's 'surprising' mistake enhance questions about his man Utd destiny?

He has been a mainstay in the Manchester United purpose for extra than a decade, but is David de Gea’s antique Trafford future now within the balance?

The Spaniard made a horrendous mistake to gift said Benrahma a purpose that proved to be the winner for West Ham on Sunday, unfavorable the purple Devils’ hopes of finishing inside the highest quality League’s pinnacle four inside the technique.

The 32-yr-vintage has now made four mistakes main to a goal in all competitions this season, the joint maximum of any greatest League participant, together with Hugo Lloris.

In February De Gea stated settlement talks at old Trafford might “lead to a very good manner” and he become “taking part in it” – however for many lovers and pundits this may be one mistake too many.

“If he’s in contract negotiations, making errors like that is never going to help,” former Liverpool, Tottenham and Stoke striker Peter Crouch instructed BT game.

“he is been a top-magnificence goalkeeper over time, but at the moment it appears like he is making big errors in massive, big video games.

“David de Gea has had a shocker, we can not get dressed it up. You cannot justify it at all, it’s a terrible mistake.”

West Ham aspect to win over man Utd
Have your say on De Gea’s future at United
Former Newcastle and Tottenham midfielder Jermaine Jenas become equally vital, telling BT sport: “it’s beyond surprising. His crew is in full manage of this sport and to let one in like that. he will understand himself.”

Former Manchester United defender Rio Ferdinand brought: “it’s a awful mistake. he’ll take full responsibility for that.

“His left foot does slip barely but it really is no excuse, he is got complete contact at the ball. it’s now not like he’s stretching and getting fingertips on it.”

‘Each person has to take duty’

There’s no doubting De Gea’s pedigree. He has made more than 500 United appearances when you consider that arriving from Atletico Madrid in 2011, prevailing the membership’s participant of the year award 4 times and lifting the top of the line League, FA Cup, League Cup and Europa League trophies.
Unsurprisingly supervisor Erik ten Hag leapt to the player’s defence, pointing out that he is in rivalry for the ultimate League Golden Glove after maintaining 15 easy sheets thus far this season – greater than all and sundry else.
“errors are a part of football and in this crew you need to address it and bounce back due to the fact it is a crew game,” said the Dutchman.
“Over the season he is the one with the most clean sheets and also we did it as a crew. it is able to take place, it’s football but every body has to take duty.”
however together with his contract because of expire on the end of the season mistakes like Sunday are not going to assist negotiations and go away the purple Devils boss with a choice to make.
Ferdinand says it’s miles De Gea’s potential along with his toes instead of any difficulty along with his shot-preventing which could spark off Ten Hag to make a alternate.
“The query mark approximately him I assume is whether he is desirable sufficient with his toes to play the Erik ten Hag way,” he stated.
“In terms of shot-preventing, he is made a mistake nowadays – however that is not the vicinity I question him. Is he a great enough footballer to play for Manchester United?
“The handiest individual that may answer this is Erik ten Hag and we will recognize on the stop of this season.”
Crouch brought: “it is a atypical one, due to the fact he is conceded goals from his own mistakes however he is also kept the most clean sheets in the league.”

‘It definitely is time for United to move on from De Gea’ – your views

Jonny: certainly do not know what has took place to De Gea this season. From a regular participant of the year contender to a fair extra liability than Lloris in only 365 days. Renewing his settlement now looks as if one of the worst mistakes we could make.

Andrew: It really is time for United to transport on from De Gea. His loss of excellent dispensing the ball is already at odds with what Ten Hag appears to need from his goalkeeper, and there are just too many mistakes in his game now.

Richard: In a sport we ought to win, De Gea is doing us no favours. Abysmal goalkeeping.

Seth: while we are saying De Gea is not excellent sufficient, this is simply an example. The range of mistakes he remodeled the previous couple of years, especially underneath Ole [Gunnar Solskjaer] and now below Ten Hag is first-rate. there may be no manner he have to be a starter next season if we need to move forward.

Calum: sadly there is very little location for sentiment in recreation in case you’re seeking to construct a prevailing crew, so it is time for De Gea to move in my opinion.

ultra-modern Manchester United information, analysis and fan perspectives
Get guy Utd information notifications
pay attention to the ultra-modern The Devils’ advocate podcast