The ITV drama “Mr Bates vs The Post Office” is receiving praise from critics. Starring Toby Jones, the show portrays the real-life campaign to uncover the Post Office Horizon IT scandal.
Starring Toby Jones, the series follows the campaign to expose the Post Office Horizon IT scandal.
The initial episode of ITV’s “Mr Bates vs The Post Office” has garnered predominantly positive reviews from critics after its New Year’s Day premiere. Based on the true story of postmaster Alan Bates, portrayed by Toby Jones, the drama delves into the crusade to expose the Post Office Horizon IT scandal.
The Telegraph hailed it as “undeniably powerful and ultimately redemptive,” while the Independent suggested that the series might benefit from heightening its dramatic elements.
Airing as a four-part mini-series throughout the week on ITV, the show concentrates on Bates’ monumental legal fight, ultimately leading to the overturning of numerous convictions.
Awarding the debut episode four stars, Jasper Rees from the Telegraph remarked, “Fueled by a sense of righteous anger and sheer disbelief toward corporate misconduct that remains inexplicable, it’s unquestionably potent and, ultimately, redemptive.” He added, “There’s a pervasive notion we hold onto, isn’t there? That people can’t be that terrible. I’ve seldom felt as guided by a drama, and yet, seldom have I felt less resentment towards it.”
Rebecca Nicholson from The Guardian awarded the series four stars, acknowledging its occasional overblown nature. She likened its initial tone to an episode of Black Mirror, finding it as distressing as the darkest dystopian scenarios from that show. Despite occasional broad strokes in the storytelling, significant moments were highlighted emphatically, justified by the hard-earned triumphs deserving such grandeur, often accentuated by powerful musical scores.
Carol Midgley from The Times gave the series a four-star rating, expressing how the Post Office Horizon scandal’s intensity made it challenging for her to watch. She found the portrayal of decent people enduring mental torture and being unjustly stripped of their livelihoods deeply unsettling, making the show uncomfortably compelling. Midgley emphasized the disbelief that such events occurred in modern Britain, where innocent individuals suffered prison time for crimes they didn’t commit.
Martin Robinson of the Evening Standard praised the cast for humanizing the Kafkaesque situation. He compared it to the BBC’s Jimmy Saville series, acknowledging its gripping yet disturbing nature, highlighting its importance in showcasing a scandal that had mostly been conveyed through print media.
Nick Hilton of The Independent, while appreciating the talented cast, awarded the drama three stars. Hilton noted that delving into the technical aspects of the Horizon system didn’t lend itself well to dramatic storytelling. He expressed concerns about audience engagement throughout the series, citing the need for more gripping elements in what he perceived as a human drama lacking in dynamism.
Read More: EastEnders: Max Bowden leaving role as Ben Mitchell
Leave a Comment